After 50 years, is Black Scholes ready to retire yet?

This month marks the 50th anniversary of the Black-Scholes model, a groundbreaking formula that has shaped the financial world in remarkable ways. 

Developed by economists Fischer Black and Myron Scholes and first published in May 1973, the model offers a framework for pricing options, specifically European-style call and put options. Despite its seemingly niche focus, the Black-Scholes model has had far-reaching effects on finance, crypto, and investing. 

In this article, we’ll delve into its history, importance, updates, usefulness, and criticisms - and look at why Black-Scholes may soon be nearing retirement after half a century as the go-to model for risk pricing. Hold on tight…

‍

Black-Scholes - A Brief History

The Black-Scholes model was born out of the need to assign a fair value to options, which are financial instruments that provide the right, but not the obligation, to buy or sell an asset at a specified price within a specific time frame. 

Before the model's inception, pricing options was a subjective and often inconsistent process. Black and Scholes' innovative approach addressed this issue by quantifying the variables that affect an option's price, creating a more transparent and efficient market.

‍

Impact and Importance of Black-Scholes

The Black-Scholes model has had a profound impact on the world of finance, transforming the way options are traded and spawning a whole new industry of derivatives. 

By providing a standardized method for pricing options, it has allowed market participants to better manage risk and unlock new investment opportunities. The model has been particularly instrumental in the growth of the options market, with the establishment of the Chicago Board Options Exchange (CBOE) in 1973.

The model's influence goes beyond the traditional financial sector. In recent years, it has found applications in the burgeoning world of cryptocurrency, where options and other derivative products are gaining traction. The Black-Scholes model has served as a valuable tool for pricing crypto options, providing investors with a means to hedge against the volatile nature of digital assets.

‍

How does the Black-Scholes model work?

Ok, let’s talk about how Black-Scholes works, and examine the key inputs that drive its calculations.

These inputs, which include the risk-free rate, implied volatility, and other factors, are used to determine the fair value of an option.

• Asset/Stock price (S): The current price of the underlying asset for which the option is being priced. The asset price is a critical input, as the value of the option is directly related to the value of the underlying asset.
  
  
• Strike price (K): The predetermined price at which the holder of the option has the right to buy (for a call option) or sell (for a put option) the underlying asset. The difference between the stock price and the strike price largely determines the option's intrinsic value.
  
  
• Time to expiration (T): The time remaining until the option's expiration date. The Black-Scholes model assumes that options lose value as they approach their expiration date due to time decay. As such, the time to expiration is an essential factor in determining the option's time value.
  
  
• Risk-free rate (r): The theoretical return on a risk-free investment, such as a government bond. The Black-Scholes model factors in the risk-free rate to account for the time value of money, as it represents the opportunity cost of investing in the option versus a risk-free alternative.
  
  
• Implied volatility (IV): A measure of the expected future price fluctuations of the underlying asset. It is derived from the market prices of options on the asset and represents the market's expectation of the asset's volatility. Higher implied volatility increases the option's time value, as it suggests that the option has a higher probability of becoming profitable before expiration.
  
  
• Dividends (optional): If the underlying asset pays dividends, the Black-Scholes model can be adjusted to account for the impact of these cash flows on the option's value. Dividends typically reduce the value of call options and increase the value of put options, as they lower the expected future price of the underlying asset.

‍

And here’s how these inputs are calculated mathematically:

Call option price (C) = S * N(d1) - K * e^(-r * T) * N(d2)

Put option price (P) = K * e^(-r * T) * N(-d2) - S * N(-d1)

Here, 'e' denotes the base of the natural logarithm (approximately 2.718), and 'N(x)' represents the cumulative distribution function of the standard normal distribution.

The variables 'd1' and 'd2' are intermediate calculations, defined as:

d1 = (ln(S / K) + (r + (IV^2) / 2) * T) / (IV * sqrt(T))

d2 = d1 - IV * sqrt(T)

‍

By incorporating these inputs into its calculations, the Black-Scholes model provides a standardized method for determining the fair value of an option. 

‍

Black-Scholes Adaptations

Over the years, the Black-Scholes model has been updated and refined to address certain limitations and better suit evolving market conditions. 

One notable adaptation is the Black-Scholes-Merton model, which incorporates the possibility of early exercise for American-style options. 

Other variations have been developed to accommodate dividend-paying stocks, interest rate fluctuations, and different types of options, such as barrier and exotic options.

‍

Usefulness and Innovations

The Black-Scholes model has paved the way for various financial innovations. For example, its application in portfolio management has led to the rise of risk-neutral pricing and the advent of the delta-hedging strategy, a popular risk management technique used by options traders to mitigate the risk associated with changes in the underlying asset's price. 

Delta-hedging involves adjusting the position in the underlying asset or its derivatives to maintain a delta-neutral portfolio, effectively reducing the sensitivity of the option's value to price fluctuations.

Additionally, it has given birth to sophisticated financial products such as volatility derivatives, and options on futures as well as making the creation of structured products possible. 

These are complex financial instruments that combine multiple assets or derivatives to achieve specific investment objectives often involving the use of options to provide tailored risk-return profiles for investors. Examples include equity-linked notes, principal-protected notes, and reverse convertible securities.

There’s no doubt that the Black Scholes model has been absolutely instrumental as a tool for financial products and services over the past 50 years, but that hasn’t left it immune to criticism.

‍

Criticisms of Black-Scholes

Despite its transformative impact, the Black-Scholes model has faced its share of criticism. 

One key limitation is its reliance on several assumptions, such as constant volatility, lognormal asset price distribution, and frictionless markets. In practice, these assumptions often do not hold true, resulting in potential pricing inaccuracies.

Another critique is the model's inability to account for events like market crashes and extreme price movements, which have become increasingly relevant in today's interconnected global markets.

This has been especially amplified by voices such as legendary investor Warren Buffet who believes that the model fails to consider some essential variables, saying they can lead to ‘silly results’.

• WARREN BUFFETT

‍

Black-Scholes new challenger - Bumper

While the Black-Scholes model has been a dominant force in options pricing and risk management for five decades, it is now facing competition thank to recent innovations in decentralized finance that aim to revolutionize hedging for the crypto age. 

One such contender is Bumper, a DeFi platform that eschews the Black-Scholes model in favor of a novel approach to providing downside protection and generating sustainable yields. One of the key things that Bumper addresses is Warren Buffett’s chief criticism of Black-Scholes, because, rather than relying on past volatility, Bumper prices based on actual volatility during the term of the position.

This is a completely radical idea, which previously has been impractical to implement because of the risk of the counterparty failing to deliver on expiration (and this is especially true in the tradFi markets).

However, Bumper solves this by using a combination of peer-to-pool liquidity, and by employing smart contracts to manage the ecosystem - and smart contracts mean that code is law. 

Thus, there is no need for any third party to be involved at all, and this permissionless mechanism is just one example that highlights DeFi’s superiority to TradFi.

Astonishingly, although Bumper’s methodology is radically different from the Black-Scholes formula, Simulations have shown that Bumper's pricing exhibits an intriguing correlation to the 50 year-old model, in many cases providng more price-efficient risk protection while still generating sustainable yields for liquidity providers. 

As a decentralized platform governed by smart contracts, Bumper is accessible to anyone with a web3 wallet like MetaMask, opening the doors to a new era of hedging and risk management in the crypto space.

Find out more about Bumper and why this novel protocol has the ability to supercede the half-century old Black-Scholes formula for good.

‍